Waldorf MD Real Estate: Homeownership – This Time the Wall Street Journal Got it Wrong
This article was written a few years ago. It covers the value of home ownership and renting. But it also includes some great insight into the world of Stocks, Interest rates, and Home Values. It looks at Purchasing your Waldorf MD Home from various perspectives from some Harvard folks. Take the time to read this article if you are interested in purchasing or renting a home in Southern Maryland.
written by: Steve Harney
I have been a subscriber to the Wall Street Journal (WSJ) for as long as I can remember. In my opinion, it is the single greatest source of financial information and insights available. I don’t always agree with their analysis but I always respect their position.
However, in an article this past weekend, The New Math of Renting vs. Buying, they flat out got it wrong. Below are a few excerpts from the article and the reason why I believe the analysis to be incorrect.
The Cost of Renting is Lower than the Cost of Owning
In the article, they discuss that homeownership is more expensive than renting in many large metropolitan areas.
“The monthly cost of renting was lower than buying in 20 large metropolitan areas at the end of last year, the most recent period for which data are available, according to figures provided exclusively to The Wall Street Journal by Deutsche Bank. That is up from 15 large metropolitan areas a year earlier.”
The challenge is that more recent data from two very reliable sources has shown that not to be the case. Among the 35 largest metro areas analyzed by Zillow in the first quarter, every metro showed it would be cheaper to buy than rent if you plan to live in the home for at least 4.2 years.
According to a study by Trulia:
“Homeownership remains cheaper than renting nationally and in all of the 100 largest metro areas. Rising mortgage rates and home prices have narrowed the gap over the past year, though rates have recently dropped and price gains are slowing. Now, at a 30-year fixed rate of 4.5%, buying is 38% cheaper than renting nationally.” (emphasis added)
Renters Don’t Have All the Expenses of Homeowners
The article goes on to explain that as a renter you have many less expenses than you would have as a homeowner:
“Renters, for example, don’t pay property taxes, homeowner’s insurance and, in most cases, maintenance costs. These expenses can cost homeowners about 3% of the price of their home annually, experts say.
While those costs can be folded into monthly rent, apartment renters often pay a smaller share as landlords spread the costs among many tenants, says Stijn Van Nieuwerburgh, director of the Center for Real Estate Finance Research at New York University. If a window breaks or the toilet plugs up, your landlord—not you—pays for the repairs.”
Don’t kid yourself – the landlord does not pay the taxes nor pay for repairs. The tenant does. It is incorporated in the rent. It is true, if it is an apartment building, that the property taxes are shared by all tenants. However, realize that the amount of property taxes for an apartment building with “many tenants” will be far greater than a single family residence.
We think this situation is best explained by Eric Belsky, Managing Director of the Joint Center of Housing Studies at Harvard University, in his paper on homeownership – The Dream Lives On: the Future of Homeownership in America:
“Households must consume housing whether they own or rent. Not even accounting for more favorable tax treatment of owning, homeowners pay debt service to pay down their own principal while households that rent pay down the principal of a landlord plus a rate of return. That’s yet another reason owning often does—as Americans intuit—end up making more financial sense than renting.”(emphasis is mine)
Investing the Difference in Payments Will Net a Renter More Money
The WSJ article claims that, if a renter invests the difference between their rent payment and a potential mortgage payment had they purchased, they would be better off financially in the long run.
“Renters don’t end up with a valuable asset, as buyers do when they pay off a mortgage. But renters might be able to make more money by investing the monthly savings, as well as the cash they would otherwise use for a down payment, he says.”
They go on to explain their reasoning as follows:
“The value of the average single-family home increased by 3.6% a year in the three decades through 2013, compounded annually, according to mortgage giant Freddie Mac. By contrast, the compound annual return on the S&P 500 over that period was 11.1%, according to Chicago-based investment-research firm Morningstar.”
As to the idea that the return on investment would be greater by investing in the stock market rather than purchase a home, I think the article in the WSJ forgot that housing is a leveraged investment. Belsky, in his paper, explains:
“Few households are interested in borrowing money to buy stocks and bonds and few lenders are willing to lend them the money. As a result, homeownership allows households to amplify any appreciation on the value of their homes by a leverage factor. Even a hefty 20 percent down payment results in a leverage factor of five so that every percentage point rise in the value of the home is a 5 percent return on their equity. With many buyers putting 10 percent or less down, their leverage factor is 10 or more.”
That 3.6% average annual appreciation is really an 18% return on cash to a home buyer putting down 20%.
They also assume the renter will save any difference in housing expense. However, that does not happen in reality. In their ongoing research for their paper, Beer and Cookies Impact on Homeowners’ Wealth Accumulation, Eli Beracha and Ken H. Johnson reveal that homeownership creates a ‘forced savings’ plan:
“It appears that homeownership creates extra wealth mainly through its ability to force owners to save rather than through property appreciation. Thus, homeownership appears to be a self-imposed savings plan, which through time leads to greater wealth accumulation as compared to comparable renters. In short, buying a home makes Americans save.”
And Belsky from Harvard agrees:
“Since many people have trouble saving and have to make a housing payment one way or the other, owning a home can overcome people’s tendency to defer savings to another day.”
To further make this point, we can look at a study by the Federal Reserve which showed that the net worth of a homeowner ($174,500) is 30 times greater than that of renter ($5,100).
Waldorf MD Real Estate Review
After reading the article you still see purchasing a home in Waldorf MD is a better idea. Looking at financial advantages of homeownership from every angle still reveals that it is a much better investment than renting.
If you are looking to Buy a Home in Southern Maryland, hire a Southern Maryland Realtor to help you find the Home you are looking for. In either Charles County, St. Mary’s County, Prince Georges County, Calvert County or Anne Arundel County, Finding and Hiring a local Realtor will help you find the right home for the right price. If its New Construction you need, your local Maryland Realtor can help you find the right Community or even find the right On Your Lot with Caruso Homes to build your Luxury Dream Home. What is your house value. Home value comes from the sales of other properties in your community that have sold over the last 6 months. When your house is prepared to go on the market, the value is calculated by Bedrooms, Bathrooms, Square Footage, Garage and Basement. Location also plays a part in the value of your home. If your in a good location, close to shopping, in a great school district, this will attract more potential buyers to your home. Making the home value much higher and also opening up the possibility of selling your home much faster. Taking also into the factor that when buying a New Luxury home from Caruso Home – On Your Lot, you have the opportunity to get your new home built for less than regular market value. Always give New Construction of your purchase a chance to see if you have the 7 – 9 months of build time. Caruso Homes also has communities all around Maryland that have homes that are 30 – 45 days out for you to purchase as well. Buying new will give you the value and equity to grow in your investment.
Please leave a message below and I will return your homes valuation, time to sell on the market and any other information on your neighborhood statistics.
Sorry we are experiencing system issues. Please try again.
Skip Young Realtor
is rated 5 stars on Google based on 3 reviews
04/10/2018 – williamrichmondinc
Sold a Single Family home in 2010 in Mechanicsville, MD.
- Local knowledge:
- Process expertise:
- Negotiation skills:
I tried unsuccessfully for four years to sell my home in Mechanicsville. Two different real estate companies declined to renew my listing. Thank goodness for Skip Young. He never gave up and never made any excuses – and this was at a time when the real estate market was at it’s absolute worst. We had some offers that fell through at the last minute. Skip never wavered. His attitude was always positive. Thanks to Skip’s tenacity and professionalism my house sold and I got the fresh start I needed. Thank you Skip.
|2004 Rookie of the Year Southern Maryland|
10665 Stanhaven Place Suite 300
White Plains, MD 20695
Mon-Sat 8am – 6pm
Skip Young | Caruso Homes | On Your Lot Division
Maryland Homes For Sale
Homes for Sale Indian Head MD 20640 | Homes for Sale La Plata MD 20646 | Homes for Sale Port Tobacco MD 20677 | Homes for Sale Bryans Road MD 20616 | Homes for Sale Bryantown MD 20617 | Homes for Sale Cobb Island MD 20625 | Homes for Sale Hughesville MD 20637 | Homes for Sale Pomfret MD 20675 | | Homes for Sale Waldorf MD 20601, 20602, 20603, 20604 | Homes for Sale Nanjemoy MD 20622 | Homes for Sale Newburg MD 20664 | Homes for Sale Welcome MD 20693 | Homes for Sale White Plains MD 20695 | 20640 | Homes for Sale in 20646 | Homes for Sale in 20677 | Homes for Sale in 20616 | Homes for Sale in 20617 | Homes for Sale in 20625 | Homes for Sale in 20637 | Homes for Sale 20675 | Homes for Sale20601, 20602, 20603, 20604 | Homes for Sale 20611 | Homes for Sale 20622 | Homes for Sale 20664 | Homes for Sale 20693 | Homes for Sale 20695
Infographic by KCM Crew
Buying or Selling Real Estate in Maryland, Servicing these area’s.
Bowie, Waldorf, Coltons Point, Bryantown, Barstow, Solomons, Mechanicsville, Fort Washington, Brandywine, Oxon Hill, Annapolis, Aquasco, Dameron, Welcome, Cobb Island, Helen, Issue, Lexington Park, Hughesville, Lusby, Lothian, Temple Hills, Morganza, Callaway, Cheltenham, Piney Point, Port Tobacco, Bel Alton, Faulkner, White Plains, Pomfret, Benedict, Huntingtown, Marbury, Churchton, Greenbelt, Edgewater, Dowell, Port Republic, Ridge, Scotland, Clinton, Hollywood, Saint Inigoes, Prince Frederick, Bushwood, Tall Timbers, Odenton, Clements, Bryans Road, Valley Lee, Chesapeake Beach, Broomes Island, Leonardtown, Patuxent River, Saint Marys City, North Beach, Rock Point, California, Saint Leonard, Indian Head, Gambrills, Davidsonville, Crofton, Chaptico, La Plata, Mayo, Charlotte Hall, West River, Dunkirk, Deale, Abell, Owings, Nanjemoy, Park Hall, Harwood, Compton, Great Mills, Ironsides, Loveville, Sunderland, Tracys Landing, Mount Victoria, Drayden, Shady Side, Avenue
Sorry we are experiencing system issues. Please try again.
June 11th, 2019
Rent or Buy when PCSing to Forte Meade MD
Rent or Buy during my next PCS? In The Fort Meade real estate market where home prices are rising, many have begun to reexamine the idea of buying a home, choosing instead, to rent for a while. But often, there is a dilemma: should you keep paying rent, knowing that rent is rising too, or should you lock in your housing cost and buy a home? Let’s look at both scenarios and analyze the pros and cons of each: Renting Around Fort Meade MD With the housing market crash in 2008, many homeowners lost their homes and became renters. According to
June 10th, 2019
4 Reasons To Buy A Home This Summer in Waldorf MD
Buying a Home today instead of waiting. 1. Prices Will Continue to Rise in Waldorf MD CoreLogic’s latest U.S. Home Price Insights reports that home prices have appreciated by 3.7% over the last 12 months. The same report predicts that prices will continue to increase at a rate of 4.8% over the next year. Home values will continue to appreciate. Waiting may no longer makes sense. 2. Mortgage Interest Rates Are Projected to Increase Freddie Mac’s Primary Mortgage Market Survey shows that interest rates for a 30-year fixed rate mortgage have started to level off around 4.3%. Most experts predict that…
May 16th, 2019
VA Home Loan did you know? Skip Young Fort Meade MD Realtor
The VA home loan is a mortgage loan option offered exclusively to active-military service members, veterans, and surviving spouses. VA loans are financed through private lenders and guaranteed by the Department of Veterans Affairs. 1. SAVE THOUSANDS NO MORTGAGE INSURANCE FEE 2. 0% DOWN PAYMENT 3. NO PRE-PAYMENT PENALTIES 4. DISABILITY BENEFITS 5. GOOD FOR MORE THAN ONE USE
May 11th, 2019
Seller’s 4 Options when your house does not sell | Skip Young
When you house does not sell in Maryland, you bring in Skip Young. When a listing expires, every seller has four options. That’s when you’ll see the described human behavior patterns come into play. 1. Re-list with their current real estate professional ( Real Estate Ethics from Skip Young) 2. Take the house off the market 3. List the house For-Sale-By-Owner (FSBO) 4. Contract with Skip Young to Sell Your Home in Maryland • Option 1: Re-list with their current real estate professional For whatever reason, your house did not sell in Maryland. Perhaps you now realizes how difficult the housing market…